Listening to the whole album of Scarlet and Other Stories I have come to realize that I really am in a much different place, mentally, than when this came out. This was my favorite All About Eve album forever, and now I know why: it is the most beautiful, melancholy album they made. Is it still my favorite Eves album now? I'm not completely sure. In October of 1989 I was a senior in high school and at, pretty much, the height of my Goth loving era. I had discovered how much I appreciated the beauty of female vocals through the Eves self-titled debut album.